Representatives of the European Union fishing industry are calling a mackerel quota agreement between the U.K., Norway, and the Faroe Islands disappointing in the face of continued overfishing of the stock.

The governments of the U.K., Norway, and Faroe Islands agreed to a series of fisheries arrangements for the Northeast Atlantic mackerel stock – a stock shared between the three countries and the E.U., Iceland, and Greenland. In October, all six member states agreed to a total allowable catch (TAC) of 739,386 metric tons (MT) – in line with scientific advice from the International Council for the Exploration of the Seas (ICES).

That agreement, however, does not specify how each member state will divide the TAC. The agreement between U.K., Norway, and Faroe Islands will see the three catching a total of 531,129 MT of the quota – leaving 208,257 MT, or 28 percent, of the TAC to the three remaining member states. In a release, the governments of the U.K., Norway, and Faroe Islands said the new agreement was purposely designed with the other three members in mind.

Europêche and the European Association of Fish Producers Organisations (EAPO) disagreed with that assessment and said the agreement will only continue the critical issues the Northeast Atlantic mackerel fishery has faced. The species was one of multiple pelagic species that lost Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) certification in 2020 after continued overfishing, and multiple organizations have issued repeated calls for action to stop overfishing.

“This agreement does not solve the critical issue of catches exceeding the TAC set in line with scientific advice. Instead, it rewards the setting of excessive, inflated unilateral quotas by some parties in recent years,” Europêche and EAPO said in a joint statement. “Therefore, the E.U. industry urges all coastal states to resume their consultations on a comprehensive sharing arrangement that should reflect genuine, sustainable track records and interests.”